Last year, we pondered if any release could possibly defeat Grand Theft Auto 6 for the 2025 Game of the Year award — "aside from Rockstar's capability to finish it on schedule." Ultimately, it was precisely that that took Rockstar's highly-anticipated game from the running, with pushbacks to May and, subsequently, November 2026 clearing the path for Clair Obscur: Expedition 33's remarkable clean sweep at The 2025 Game Awards.
Consequently, gazing forward to GOTY 2026, we are situated with a powerful sense of familiarity. Yet again, GTA 6 starts the year as the clear top contender to win the top award. Once again, Rockstar's biggest enemy may prove to be its own punctuality. Even though another delay at this point is less likely, it's definitely still conceivable, and with its announced Nov. 19 release date barely making into The Game Awards' standard eligibility window, it would need merely a slide of a couple of days or more to relegate GTA 6 into contention for the 2027 awards.
Yet again, GTA 6 appears remarkably tough to defeat, but not entirely unbeatable. Rockstar's own Red Dead Redemption 2 was surpassed for GOTY by Sony Santa Monica's God of War in 2018, while GTA 5 was overshadowed in most awards ceremonies and GOTY votes — except perhaps at the Game Awards' forerunner, VGX — by The Last of Us. Paradoxically, GTA 6's colossal status is a paradoxical kind of liability, as critics and awards panels will be eagerly seeking out an appealing alternative angle to embrace in order to prevent a foregone conclusion.
So what alternative titles could pose a challenge? Predicting nominees this so soon in the year is, frankly, a rather a speculative endeavor: the landscape of indie and smaller releases is very uncertain, while bigger games frequently get delayed or don't pan out, and various publishers (including Nintendo) have yet to announce their titles for the latter part of the year. However, there are already a small group of 2026 releases that appear to be they will be serious contenders. Here are five that stand a strong chance of being shortlisted together with GTA 6.
1. Control: Resonant
Remedy Entertainment's psychologically thrilling sequel is arguably the strongest challenger to GTA 6's hegemony. Indeed, Remedy may well be the ideal Game Awards studio: It crafts highly polished, graphically impressive, story-rich action-adventure games while working just sufficiently outside the industry center to still feel like an underdog. The original Control secured eight nominations and one win in 2019, while Alan Wake 2 ran Baldur's Gate 3 a close second in 2023, turning three of its eight nominations into wins in the coveted Game Direction, Narrative, and Art Direction categories. After a spectacular trailer debut at the 2025 Awards, Control Resonant is never to be underestimated.
2. Resident Evil: Requiem
A fresh (or, similarly) remade Resident Evil game is has a higher probability to be nominated for Game of the Year than to miss out. This venerable series has an excellent recent history at The Game Awards — Resident Evil 2 was nominated for the main prize in 2019, Village in 2021, and 4 in 2023 — in addition to a reputation for consistent quality. It must be said, a win would be a much more unlikely proposition, but you can count on Capcom finding itself in the mix.
3. Marvel’s Wolverine
The Wolverine game from Insomniac is one of the largest blockbuster prospects of the year, and in terms of budget and polish, almost certainly one of the select group that will be able to give GTA 6 a run for its money. Like Resident Evil, Insomniac's slick Marvel games series is great at accumulating lots of nominations at The Game Awards, and weaker at transforming them into wins. Will the shift from Spider-Man to an darker character and (far) more visceral action alter the dynamic in Wolverine's favor? Perhaps, and it will be Sony's primary contender for the year, which virtually secures it a spot at the main event.
4. Fortune's Weave (Fire Emblem)
Nintendo is seldom absent from the list of Game of the Year nominees. Without a clear idea of what its major 2026 game will be (a new core Pokémon and a 3D Mario game are both rumored), Fortune’s Weave makes a viable placeholder. Fire Emblem is a niche series, it's true, but it has been building gradually in both fanbase and acclaim over the past few years, while its involved anime storytelling style and tactical combat get more popular and closer to the gaming establishment by the day. It would not be a shock.
5. The Blood of Dawnwalker
The increasingly influential European voting contingent on the jury is steadily making its presence felt, notably when it comes to nominating big, ambitious Euro role-playing games like Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2. Rebel Wolves' first game is an prime game to attract those votes and fill this slot, notably given the Witcher 3 lineage of its developers — and its striking resemblance to that 2015 GOTY winner.
Concerning the Indies?
The glaring omission in our list is that it lacks an indie contender. While The Game Awards jury generally only nominates one indie game for Game of the Year — 2025's three of indie picks looks like a exception — it also hardly ever fails to nominate one. It's nearly impossible to guess what that game might be at this point, as the biggest indie games of each year often come out of the blue, but a few potential candidates would be:
- Mixtape: a music-centric, sentimental road trip of a game supported by the influential publishers at Annapurna Interactive.
- Replaced: a long-awaited cyberpunk adventure with a beautifully detailed pixel-art visual style.
- Ontos: Frictional Games' secretive follow-up to the Amnesia series (provided it's not overly horrifying).
- Slay the Spire 2: sequel to the immensely popular roguelike deckbuilder (but it could fail to make it out of early access in 2026).
- Mina the Hollower: Yacht Club Games' Shovel Knight successor, an whimsical retro Zelda homage (assuming the studio can finally finish it).
Additional Challengers
- Gears of War: E-Day: One of two huge franchise revivals from Xbox Game Studios in 2026, E-Day will have to prove that this very 2000s series is still pertinent.
- Fable: After